Friday, August 01, 2008

Gaydar by the numbers. Just How Accurate Is It?

Gay-dar, Quantified

How long does it take to decide if a man is gay?

It turns out that people make their decisions within 50 milliseconds of seeing someone, and that first instinct is accurate the majority of the time, according to research by Nick Rule and Nalini Ambady of Tufts University who have a study in an upcoming issue of the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology.
Via BPS Research Digest

Twenty-two male and sixty-eight female undergrads were presented with photos of 90 men's faces (half were homosexual) .

The anonymous photos were taken from an internet dating site where posters stated their sexual orientation.

Any photos featuring facial hair, glasses or jewelery were not used. (Now that sucks. All bears with facial hair ere excluded f rom the process)

At a quick glance, the presentation was too quick for the students to consciously 'see' the faces and, perhaps unsurprisingly, their ability to determine the men's sexuality was no better than if they were simply guessing.

However, at a slightly longer glance - just long enough for the faces to be consciously seen - the students' accuracy grew to 57 per cent, which is significantly better than chance performance.

Accuracy didn't increase with the longer exposure times, suggesting that all the relevant information for making the judgment had already been extracted after a quick glance.

In a second study, the researchers guarded against the possibility that the men in the dating photographs had deliberately accentuated their sexuality. This time photos were taken from the social website Facebook, where they had been posted by people other than the subjects of the photos (so deliberate accentuation of sexuality was less likely). Again, from just a glance exposure to men's faces, the 15 undergraduate participants were able to recognise the men's sexual orientation with an accuracy better than chance.

But that 57 percent success rate means that almost half of the guys initially perceived to be gay aren't.

I don't think this really proves anything. But it's a fun topic to banter around during your next cookout.


Lemuel said...

I always assume that I have very weak and ill-defined gaydar, but I have a lot of fun trying to guess! :)

K-A said...

This is an interesting study, but I wonder why men with facial hair were removed?

Anyhow, I liked to say I have a damaged gaydar because it doesn't work. It's always been that way for me all my life. There are those who are obvious, but then there are those I generally can't tell.

It's embarrassing because sometimes my straight friends have to tell me that some guy was flirting with me.

Now that I live in exile it is especially difficult because guys here are so completely closeted and I miss out on all the signals.

Masculine Men said...

Em here from the Masculine Man Blog. Thanks for posting a comment - I like your blog too!


P.S. - Big, Hairy hugs right back at ya =).

Leonard said...

So someone can actually "look gay"..interesting...;) peace

Mac Callister said...

i think gay men are all equipped with the gayday hehe,we somehow notice it by looking at the guy in front of us,but ofcourse not at all time,there are bunch of gays out there that you cant really tell